Why is My Website Getting Traffic but No Inquiries?

 

How to improve your website as a service provider

Your website is one of your business’s best assets, and it’s frustrating when you’re getting traffic, but no one is booking or inquiring. I’ve been there more than once. 


With seven years as a UX/UI Designer at tech startups and agencies, I’ve worked on consumer mobile apps, web apps, and websites, and I know which changes do the most to bring in more leads. I created this guide to help you make those improvements, so your visitors are more likely to take the action you want, whether that’s inquiring about your services, signing up for your freebie, or booking a call. These updates will strengthen your site and help your business stand out online.


Table of contents

 

Why is my website not getting any inquiries?

Think of your website as a garden. When you first plant it everything looks healthy and lovely. However, without regular tending, you’ll notice that the weeds are creeping in, maybe the path becomes overgrown, and perhaps you forgot to water it throughout the week. Eventually, what was once healthy, is no longer producing. The harvest you were hoping for isn’t there.

Your website works the same way. It isn’t something to set and forget about. Our sites need regular maintenance and check-ins. Although not as frequently as garden, every two-three months it benefits your business to take a peek at your site’s analytics. 

If you’re getting website traffic, but no one is inquiring, it’s time to make some changes. The good news is that this is usually fixable, and I’ve been here before.

 

 

Prioritize These Areas to Improve Your Website To Receive More Inquiries

Enhance your website’s UI Design

UI stands for “User Interface”. UI Design is all the visual components that make up a digital interface. Think colors, fonts, visual and text hierarchy, buttons, basically anything and everything you interact with on a digital screen.


There three areas I strongly recommend checking as these may be discouraging your site visitors from taking action:

1. Sufficient Color Contrast

Is there enough contrast between the font color and the background? Can people actually read your website or are they squinting, and not because they’re not wearing their glasses, but because the font color choice is too light. I often see this with wellness and spa brands,  where very low contrast visual branding makes their websites hard to read.

How to improve website color contrast: Use WebAIM Contrast Checker tool to check your text color against your background color. Ideally, you want to “pass” all five conformity areas, but passing the WCAG AA conformity items is considered the legal benchmark.


2. Establish Visual Hierarchy

Go to your website, and as you're scrolling through each page, squint a bit: are the headings and subheadings jumping out at you as well as the CTAs? If not, it’s lacking visual hierarchy.

You want to ensure each webpage has arranged and styled page elements in order of its importance. Using headings, subheadings, bullet points, and highlighting specific text to create visual hierarchy allows your visitors to quickly scan your website to find the information they’re looking for.

According to the Nielson Norman Group, “only 16 percent of people read word-by-word” on websites, so focus more on creating hierarchy between headings and subheadings. 

How to improve website visual hierarchy: You can fix this by creating strong color contrast for your CTAs, size and scale for your headings and sub headings.


3. Ensure Whitespace (Negative Space)

I will often hear my clients say “there’s too much empty space here”. When in actuality, there’s just the right amount of whitespace (or negative space). Whitespace gives items visual weight, can guide the eye throughout a webpage, and reduce cognitive load for your site visitors. Because whitespace can draw attention to CTAs, you’re likely to get more bookings.

How to improve website whitespace: Create wide margins on your site, consistent spacing between your headings, paragraphs, and CTAs as well as consistent vertical space between sections on each webpage. 

 

Ensure your site’s UX Design is solid

User experience (UX) design is how a person interacts with a digital interface. What they think, feel, and how they behave while using it are all aspects of UX design. At it’s core is really understanding your audience and studying them. However, if you’re in the process of learning about your people, that’s ok because luckily, we know a lot about how people interact with websites through research and behavioral tools like Hotjar.  


One thing to remember here is that people expect certain things to be consistent across websites so they don’t have to relearn how to use each one. This reduces cognitive load on our visitors. 


Here are the areas I’d improve to ensure they meet UX Design standards.

1. Clear and concise navigation

Too many navigation choices can be overwhelming and unclear for our site visitors. I think we’ve all had website experiences where the site had way too many options, and we ended up bouncing from the site because we didn’t know what page had the information we were looking for. 

How to improve your website’s navigation: I recommend sticking to five clear navigation choices. For example: home, services, about, blog, and contact. If you have a couple of services, I recommend having those as the navigation. For example, if you offer tarot and astrology readings, you can have “Astrology Readings” and “Tarot Readings” as their own navigation and thus they each have their own web page.

2. Making sure the layout looks good on mobile

The majority of people are going to come across your site on mobile. In fact, over 60 percent of searches happen on a mobile device (learn more on SEMrush’s blog post) so it’s crucial that they can use it. If the text size is too small, elements are overlapping causing readability issues, and if the layout is messy, people will bounce.

How to improve your website’s mobile layout: Ensure the text font is at least 16px, adjust elements so they aren’t clashing into each other, especially buttons. Edit the layout so it flows well from one section to the next, ensuring there aren’t massive amounts of whitespace between them.

3. Optimize page loading times

The time it takes for a web page to load directly impacts the bounce rate: the longer it takes the page to load, the higher the chance your visitor is going to leave without looking at other pages on your site.

The likely biggest culprit for gunking up your load time are images. To know if the images on your site are slowing down your web page loading time, generate a Lighthouse report for each web page in Incognito mode, and look at your Largest Contentful Paint (LCP). This indicates the time it takes for the largest item on your webpage to load which is usually an image. Identify what images are the largest per webpage.

How to improve your website’s page loading speed: Resize and compress images before adding them to your site and use WebP or AVIF format if possible. Some website platforms, like Squarespace, automatically convert file format to WebP format for supported browsers. I use the tool Squoosh.app to optimize images (resizing and compressing) for websites.

If you’re using PNG file format because you need a crisp image with a transparent background, use them sparingly as these are often larger files. I recommend keeping your images under 250kb if possible, and definitely under 500kb.

 

Your Website needs to have Quality Content 

When our sites have intentional and strategic content, it helps build trust, increases engagement, and can generate action. Although this includes all content on our sites, I’m going to speak specifically to copywriting and SEO as I touched on other areas of content in previous areas.


Here are the areas I’d consider improving:

1. Writing original content, not AI content

Copy written by AI lacks nuance because it can only work with what’s already existing on the internet. It's just regurgitating what’s already out there. This is why writing original content is so important: your ideas, insights, and messaging aren’t hanging out on the internet. Your words are likely going to provide value to your audience, and Google favors this.

How to improve if you used AI to write your entire website: If you have the budget, I strongly recommend working with a copywriter, here are a few I recommend: 

BUT if that’s not in the budget, I’d go through and edit each webpage, so it adds a human touch. Then have a friend read through it to see if it passes the human vibe test.

2. Demonstrate your expertise, experience, and trust

When you demonstrate these areas on your site, it reduces visitor uncertainty, helps with your search ranking, and can create loyal customers. 

How to demonstrate these areas: 

  1. For experience: add client testimonials, and dedicate a webpage to testimonials. Even better if you can have a few case studies. 

  2. For expertise: On your about page, provide your qualifications, credentials, courses completed, anything that speaks to why you’re an expert in what you offer.

  3. For trust: Provide privacy policies, how you use website traffic data, and provide a way to contact you whether that be by providing your email or a contact form.

3. Writing with SEO in mind

Search engines look at your webpage copy to understand what you offer and who it’s for. A few small tweaks can help your site show up when someone searches for your services.

How to improve your SEO: 

  1. Make sure you have one H1 per webpage. The H1 should include the main topic for that page or how you want to be found. 

  2. Add your location to the H1 on your homepage if you serve a specific area. For example, if you’re a psychotherapist located in Seattle, WA, you’ll want to have an H1 on your homepage that reads something along the lines of “Psychotherapist based in Seattle, WA” or "Psychotherapist taking new clients in Seattle, WA”. If you’re an online business, name your audience in your H1 on your homepage.

  3. Try to use words your customers use. Think about how your ideal client is searching for your work, and use those words in your copy, especially in H1s and H2s. This is much better than using clever phrases that no one searches for. 


There’s a lot more that goes into the SEO of your website, and if you’re curious, you can learn more about this from an easy guide that Summon and Sell created.

 

How to Create a Website Improvement Strategy 

At this point you likely have an idea of what needs tending to in order to improve your site. The trick is not trying to fix everything at once. Here’s how to build a plan you’ll actually follow: 

  1. Set a baseline before you change anything

    • Take note of your current traffic, bounce rate, number of inquiries/bookings per month. I’d capture the last three months of these analytics. This way you can measure the impact later.

  2. Audit your website

    • I promise it’s not as scary as it sounds! Open each main page and go through the 9 areas I’ve listed above. Take note of what you find on each webpage in a spreadsheet or google doc.

  3. Sort by impact and effort

    • Identify each improvement as high or low impact as it pertains to a website visitor taking action and high or low effort. Some quick wins like fixing color contrast, resizing and compressing images, come first.

  4. Start with pages that matter most

    • Your home and main services page matter the most, so improve these pages first before the other ones.

  5. Batch your work

    • Grouping similar tasks together will keep you from feeling overwhelmed and is a more efficient approach. For example: do all of your copy edits together, compression your images in one sitting. 

  6. Schedule your next site review

    • Lastly, set a reminder on your calendar to visit your website again in two to three months.

 

How to Measure the Impact of Your Improvements

After 2-3 months of implementing these changes you should begin to see more traffic to your site, your bounce rate decreasing, and more bookings and inquiries. Make sure to take note of your site’s analytics prior to implementing your improvements as you’ll want to use those numbers as your baseline.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How often should I update my website?

Review it every two to three months, and make updates as needed. You may need to implement edits sooner if your offers have changed.

2. Do I need to hire a website designer to review my site and make changes?

Most of the fixes I’ve outlined can be done yourself in platforms like Squarespace, Showit, and Wix. If you find that you’re needing help, contact me.

3. What should I fix first if I’m short on time?

Start with your homepage, and make sure color contrast is strong, your CTA stands out, and ensure it looks great on mobile.

4. How long until I see results after I’ve implemented these improvements?

It can take two-three months after making changes. Although some quick wins, like a clearer CTA, can happen sooner. Be sure to record your website analytics prior to making changes, this way you can reference them based on your analytics post implementation.

5. Is it okay to use AI to write my website copy?

The short answer is no, and I strongly discourage this. However, if it’s keeping you from improving your site, then I’d say you can use AI, BUT be sure to edit it. It needs to have a human touch.

 

 
 

Next
Next

How To create a mood board